A 1924 Westchester County estate built by the Dolly Sisters, the Hungarian-born vaudeville and Broadway twins, has hit the market for just under $2.8 million. The property, last sold nearly three decades ago, is the kind of listing that mixes entertainment history with very real high-end residential product.
What happened
- Asking price: just under $2.8 million
- Last sold nearly 30 years ago
- Built 1924, called the Dolly Sisters House locally
- About 6,200 square feet across three stories, including a garage apartment
- More than one acre, off Soundview Avenue in White Plains
- Represented by Stacey Pinkas and John Oliveira of Douglas Elliman
The property: original bones, Jazz Age soul
The marketing leans on provenance—and the bones support it. Coffered ceilings, custom millwork, a crimson-carpeted staircase and an emerald-tiled fireplace remain intact. A porte-cochère leads to a parquet-floored foyer; formal rooms open via French doors to a wraparound screened porch. Three turreted spaces house an office and library. Upstairs: four bedrooms including a primary suite with fireplace, windowed sitting area and vintage bath, plus two more rooms on the top level. A separate apartment above the two-car garage adds flexibility.
The stone and shingle exterior echoes the Newport "cottages" of the era. That architectural lineage gives a buyer something to anchor on beyond square footage. The parcel sits minutes from Westchester Hills Golf Club and downtown White Plains dining and shops.
Who should care
| Buyer type | Why this matters |
|---|---|
| Trophy-home collectors | Provenance, original detailing, celebrity-adjacent history |
| Multi-generational families | Garage apartment plus six bedrooms under one roof |
| Preservation-minded renovators | Uncommon 1920s craftsmanship in move-in condition |
| Investors | Rental income potential from separate garage unit |
| Comparables analysts | Rare public data point for upper Westchester luxury market |
Our analysis: what this means for you
For real estate watchers, this listing is less about the price and more about what it reveals.
First:** Nearly 30 years between trades is normal for trophy estates. They move on life events—family, school, estate planning—not rate cycles. Whoever buys next is not timing the market.
Second:** The property functions as a public benchmark for in-town, original-construction luxury stock in White Plains. With the garage apartment included, the usable square footage exceeds what appears in many competing listings. That matters to buyers comparing lot coverage and income potential.
Third:** Days-on-market will be the tell. This segment trades slowly in any environment; extended DOM here signals top-of-market saturation, while a quick sale suggests active regional demand from downsizers and second-home seekers.
What to watch
Watch the competing estate market in White Plains and Scarsdale for price adjustments in the next 90 days. Watch whether the listing draws open-house traffic or moves quietly. And watch the broader New York luxury market—Westchester prestige moves in tandem with Manhattan co-op and townhouse activity.
Bottom line
A listing like this is most useful as a comp anchor, not a purchase target. The value is knowing what approximately $2.8 million buys in 1924 construction on a White Plains acre, and tracking how long it takes to trade.
Key takeaways
- Just under $2.8 million, last traded nearly 30 years ago
- About 6,200 sq ft on an acre-plus, built 1924, original detailing intact
- Six bedrooms including a separate garage apartment; in-town White Plains with golf proximity
- Strong room count and rental potential differentiate from comparable listings
- Days-on-market will indicate regional prestige demand
Frequently asked questions
What is the asking price of the Dolly Sisters House?
Just under $2.8 million.
Who built the house?
Rosie and Jenny Dolly, the Hungarian-born vaudeville and Broadway twins known as the Dolly Sisters, built it in 1924.
How large is the property?
About 6,200 sq ft across three stories, on a parcel of more than one acre, including a separate apartment above a two-car garage.
Who has the listing?
Stacey Pinkas and John Oliveira of Douglas Elliman.
What makes this listing notable beyond price?
The combination of original 1920s craftsmanship, celebrity provenance, in-town White Plains location and flexible layout—particularly the garage apartment—differentiates it from typical comparables at this price point.
